Relative needs index study, South Australia and New South Wales

Summary

The Relative Needs Index (RNI) Study applied indicators of patient-perceived treatment needs (i.e. symptom-based measures of disease, and social and psychological consequences of oral diseases and disorders) and compared them to a clinical judgment of urgency of care. The RNI study sought to determine the relative need of patients attending for emergency and general dental care by assessing both patient-perceived need and a clinical determination of need stratified into a hierarchy of urgency of care.

At present there are no criteria or protocols in place that can be used to check or assess the reasonableness of a patient’s presentation for emergency dental care or even the relative need or priority of patients on the waiting list for general dental care. Currently, waiting lists for general dental care are based on a chronological queuing of patients, meaning that general dental care is offered on a ‘first come, first served’ basis to potential patients in the order they entered the waiting list. However, is this the most egalitarian approach to rationing dental care?

It may seem equitable to take the approach of ‘those who make the first claim to wanting to receive dental care by joining a waiting list should also be the first to receive the care’. However, there are clear disadvantages involved in the use of this system. It does not take into consideration a patient’s need for care or the urgency with which the care is required. One way of circumventing the problems associated with allocating dental care to patients on the basis of waiting time is to ration the care on the basis of their overall experience of oral diseases and disorders. Patients would be given priority on the waiting list depending on their reported symptoms and/or the psychosocial impact of their oral problem. Systems that give priority to patients with the greatest need first are deemed to be equitable, and should facilitate better access to adult dental care in both South Australia (SA) and New South Wales (NSW).

The data in the report derives from individual client experience of the problem presented to clinic, and is cross-matched with data provided by the assessing dentists. If client perception and dentist perception are assumed to express the pragmatic experience of access to care, the results suggest that some triaging of emergency and general patients using questions similar to the ones asked in the questionnaire may not be seen as unreasonable by both clients and service providers.

A total of 839 (91.2% of the anticipated sample) and 740 (82.2% of the anticipated sample) eligible patients requesting emergency dental care and general dental care were recruited across South Australia (SA) and New South Wales (NSW) respectively. Subjective oral health status indicators (i.e. experience of pain or other oral symptoms) and the psychosocial impact of oral disorders were examined as potential predictors of urgency of care.

Psychosocial impact was assessed by asking patients if, during the last week for emergency patients or the last four weeks for general patients, they had experienced specific events because of problems with their teeth, mouth or dentures. The study Relative needs index study, South Australia and New South Wales vii included social impact questions on toothache and other oral and facial pain, being concerned/worried about one’s dental health or appearance, avoidance of going out, ability to carry out daily activities and dental anxiety.

For the emergency sample, just over 71% of patients reported having a toothache in the last week, almost 70% indicated that they were worried about the appearance of their teeth or mouth, approximately 31% stayed home more than usual and 26.5% reported avoiding their usual leisure activities because of problems with their teeth, mouth or dentures. Variables having a statistically significant association with urgency of care included age, education, experience of toothache, pain in teeth with hot or cold food/fluids, pain in jaw while opening mouth wide, sore gums, bleeding gums, pain at night, difficulty sleeping, staying home more than usual, avoiding usual leisure activities and worry/concern about the health of one’s teeth or mouth.

For those patients seeking general dental care, almost 45% reported having a toothache in the last four weeks, 41% of the sample indicated that they were prevented from eating foods they would like to eat, just over 49% felt uncomfortable eating any foods, almost 70% indicated that they were worried about the appearance of their teeth or mouth, approximately 44% reported being embarrassed by the appearance/health of their teeth or mouth and just over 27% felt that life in general was less satisfying. Variables having a statistically significant association with urgency of care included age, usual/previous occupation, experience of toothache and various other oral and facial pain symptoms, being prevented from eating certain foods, decreased enjoyment of food and being worried/concerned or embarrassed about the appearance and health of one’s teeth or mouth.

Logistic regression was used to further examine the significant bivariate associations for each sample, and models were developed to aid in the prediction of urgency of care. Since the experience of symptoms reported by patients in each sample is somewhat different, the perceived treatment needs of emergency and general patients will also be different. These differences are accounted for by using separate models to predict urgency of care for each sample.

L Luzzi
Research Fellow
Australian Research Centre for Population Oral Health
The University of Adelaide

AJ Spencer
Professor of Social and Preventive Dentistry
School of Dentistry, The University of Adelaide

KF Roberts-Thomson
Senior Research Fellow
Australian Research Centre for Population Oral Health
The University of Adelaide

K Jones
Research Associate
Australian Research Centre for Population Oral Health
The University of Adelaide

ISSN 1321-0254
ISBN 978 1 74024 885 3
AIHW Cat. No. DEN 194
Order hardcopy

View/Download (pdf 12MB)